First Mother’s Day: The Best Jewelry Gifts for New Moms

Finding the perfect piece of jewelry to help someone special celebrate their first Mother’s Day isn’t always easy. We’ve rounded up our favorite timeless, quality pieces any new mom will love.

If you’re on the hunt for the perfect piece of jewelry for a first Mother’s Day gift, keep reading. You’ll find eight jewelry pieces we adore with prices ranging from accessible to heirloom-worthy.

Shop our First Mother’s Day Jewelry picks

woman in white tank top wearing gold necklaces

Is jewelry a good Mother’s Day gift?

In general, it’s safe to assume that jewelry is a good first Mother’s Day gift. If you’re unsure, there are two helpful questions you can ask yourself.

  1. Does the person I’m buying for typically wear jewelry?
  2. Have I been specifically instructed not to buy jewelry?

If the answer to the first question is Yes and the answer to the second is No, you should be good to go.

Do you still need some reassurance?

For many new mothers celebrating their first Mother’s Day, it can feel like an overly sentimental time. A unique piece of jewelry honoring her new status as a mother and her new baby’s life can help her feel forever connected to that time.

And, remember, jewelry doesn’t have to cost a lot of money for it to be remarkable. There are plenty of less expensive and sentimental pieces available today, especially those from smaller, handcrafted artisans like some of the pieces we share below.

Top picks: timeless jewelry for a first Mother’s Day

Below you’ll find our top picks for a first Mother’s Day jewelry. We’ve denoted pricing below each piece, but keep in mind this may change over time. Click the “shop now” button to confirm the most accurate pricing.

1. Nahiku Mother’s Ring

Handmade | $30 | 14K gold-filled

gold rings on a linen background

Delicate, dainty, and easy to stack, the Nahiku Mother’s Ring is a perfect understated nod to motherhood. Each small ring represents a child’s life, making it a lovely keepsake for the first Mother’s Day.

2. Noémie ‘Mama’ Necklace

Heirloom quality | $550 | 18K gold

woman wearing gold mama necklace

Available in a few different metals, the ‘Mama’ necklace from Noémie is an investment piece that will last for years. If you don’t want to drop over $500 on a chain (trust, we get it!), you can check out similar options here and here.

3. Mejuri Mother of Pearl Hidden Locket Necklace

Two-year warranty | $195 | 18K gold

What makes this gorgeous Mejuri Mother of Pearl Necklace so special is the small hidden compartment in the back to hide a sentimental photo or engraving. The thought of a tiny newborn photo hidden in the locket makes us well up inside.

4. Tiny Minimalist Birthstone Ring

Handmade | $21 | Recycled material

Another dainty and stackable ring favorite is the Tiny Minimalist Birthstone Ring. The price is right, it’s handmade from recycled material, and you can select the stone based on the baby’s birth month.

5. Zoe Lev Asymmetrical Initial Necklace

Customizable | $315 | 14K gold

We love the Zoe Lev Asymmetrical Initial Necklace for the edgier mom who wants to keep her little ones close to her heart. It’s customizable in length and easy to layer with any other favorite necklaces.

6. Minimalist Family Birthstone Necklace

Handmade | $36 | Gold stainless steel

Elegant and understated, the Minimalist Family Birthstone Necklace makes for a lovely way to honor any new mother with the birthstone of her recent baby. It’s an excellent option for layering and easy enough for everyday wear.

7. Heishi Customizable Name Bracelet

Handmade | Starts at $14 | Gemstone and Bead

The most casual and fun option, we love these Heishi Customizable Name Bracelets, specifically when the beads are mixed in colors, as shown above. We love the layered look of multiple names and the gold spacer bracelet.

8. Tiny Tags Script ‘Mama’ Bracelet

Made in the USA | $105 | 24K gold plated

If you like the ‘Mama’ necklace but don’t want a necklace, the Tiny Tags Script ‘Mama’ Bracelet is the way to go. We love how dainty and delicate it is, but it’s also perfect for everyday wear.

What are other good gifts for a first-time mom?

If you love the idea of first Mother’s Day jewelry gifts but want to accompany your present with a little something extra, here are a few ideas any first-time mom is sure to love. Trust us; we’re experts in this field.

  • A 90-minute massage
  • Carry-out from her favorite restaurant
  • A basket of her most-loved snacks
  • An uninterrupted nap
  • A bouquet of her favorite flowers
  • A spontaneous day date (no baby allowed)
  • A new book in her preferred genre
  • A framed photo of her and baby

Make sure to pair whatever you gift on the first Mother’s Day with a handwritten card expressing just how much she means to you and your new baby. Bonus points if you write specific examples of what makes her a wonderful mother.

Explore other Mother’s Day gift ideas

Hello Postpartum

Postpartum Resource Library

Founded by new mom and self-care author Carley Schweet, Hello Postpartum aims to help fill in the gaps in postpartum care and support. At Hello Postpartum, we aim to create an accessible community where everyone can access postpartum education, research-backed articles, and support tools.

No Comments Yet

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.